Heat Pump vs Gas Furnace: Pros and Cons

When it comes to home heating, several viable options are accessible for homeowners seeking a reliable and efficient solution to maintain a warm and cozy environment. A gas furnace and heat pumps stand out among these, each harboring its unique set of benefits and limitations, ensuring varied suitability based on distinct household needs and climatic conditions.

Gas furnaces, known for their powerful heating capabilities, have long been a staple in homes situated in extremely cold climates. On the other hand, heat pumps are applauded for their versatility and efficiency.

Pros of Gas Furnaces

When choosing a method for heating your home, it is important to consider your budget. The good news is that a new gas furnace won’t put as much strain on your wallet, at least initially.

Most types of gas furnaces cost less upfront than an equivalent heat pump, especially if you choose a low-efficiency model. This can make them an attractive option for those who want to maximize their comfort without breaking their budget. However, keep in mind that a high-efficiency model will offer larger energy savings over time, making them an exciting prospect for those looking to cut down on their long-term costs.

Secondly, gas furnaces are ideal heating systems that are an effective and reliable way to heat your home. Their lack of reliance on an outside energy source, such as electricity, makes them more reliable in the long run.

Unlike heat pumps, gas furnaces do not require regular maintenance to keep them operating at peak levels — so you will not have to worry about scheduling frequent service appointments. Plus, gas furnaces offer more control over room temperature so that you can create the perfect indoor environment without worrying about breakdowns or faults.

Cons of Gas Furnaces

Gas furnaces may be the initially more attractive option due to their lower purchase and installation costs. However, compared to newer energy-efficient models, like heat pumps, they require more energy and hence cost more money over the long term.

The main cost of running a gas furnace is its use of natural gas, which needs to be replenished frequently and can become expensive in the long run.

Gas furnaces typically need more energy to be able to heat a space due to their design, making them less energy efficient than electric furnaces. As such, having a gas furnace installed can lead to noticeably higher energy bills over time especially if the home has not been adequately insulated and sealed. Even small leaks in windows or doors can add up, drastically decreasing the energy efficiency of your gas furnace.

Moreover, although gas furnaces do produce a large amount of heat in the winter months, they are not always the most environmentally friendly option.

Through the combustion process during use, gas furnaces can emit undesired pollutants, such as carbon dioxide as well as other byproducts such as nitrogen oxides, sulfur dioxide, and particulate matter that can have detrimental effects on our health and the environment when released into the atmosphere. This goes against many people's efforts to reduce their carbon footprint and become more eco-friendly.

Finally, gas furnaces can be by far quite noisier than other heating options such as heat pumps, often producing noise levels between 50-80 decibels. The noise coming from this type of system is generated when the burners ignite, and it can be a major nuisance if it isn’t mitigated correctly. If you’re looking for ways to reduce both outdoor as well as indoor noise from your furnace, soundproofing is an ideal solution. You’ll need to place costly soundproof insulation around the furnace or use acoustic dampeners on window frames or walls where there’s greater contact with noise levels.

Pros of Heat Pumps

Heat pumps are a more energy-efficient form of heating than traditional gas furnaces for many reasons.

Heat pumps also offer a great solution for those looking to move towards a greener and more sustainable lifestyle while maintaining comfortable temperatures in their home. Unlike burning fuel, heat pumps such as Mitsibushi Electric and Bosch Thermotechnology only use electricity, meaning you do not have to worry about emissions and air quality.

Additionally, since they do not burn fuel to generate heat, you can save money on your heating bill over time. Your long-term energy savings can help offset the cost of installation against other forms of heating.

As well as Heat Pumps being cost-effective and eco-friendly, by using the outside air to heat and cool their homes, heat pumps allow families to reduce their carbon emissions and limit the amount of pollutants in the atmosphere due to the lack of combustion used in their operation.

Not only are Heat pumps more energy-efficient than gas furnaces, but they also have longer lifespans. While gas furnaces tend to become inefficient and require replacement after 10-15 years of use, heat pumps can last up to 25 years with proper maintenance and servicing.

As such, when considering the cost of not just initial installation but also the life cycle of the equipment itself, heat pumps are often the better investment for homeowners who plan on using their home heating system for a long time. Additionally, as the price of electricity stays relatively constant over time, you also have the assurance that heat pump operating costs will not fluctuate too much over its lifespan.

Finally, heat pumps are a great option for those looking for an efficient and quiet heating system for their home. Heat pumps such as Mitsibushi Electric and Bosch Thermotechnology are designed to run quietly, emitting minimal sound levels that will not disturb the peace and quiet of your home. This is a major benefit for households where people need to concentrate on work or school, have restful sleep quality at night, or simply want more tranquility in their day-to-day lives.

Cons of Heat Pumps

As much as a heat pump is a great option when it comes to home heating, there is an upfront cost that can dissuade some homeowners. This initial financial investment can be daunting, but do not let it dissuade you from considering the possible long-term cost savings with a heat pump. Thanks to modern innovations, these systems often run using much less energy than traditional furnaces, meaning that you could enjoy significant savings on your monthly electricity bills in the future.

Secondly, like most pieces of machinery, regular servicing is an essential part of keeping heat pumps working optimally. Not only will regular servicing contribute to the longevity of the pump, but it can also save you money in the long run.

If a heat pump isn't regularly serviced and maintained by a qualified technician who is knowledgeable in their operation to manufacturer's guidelines then it can lead to a drop in efficiency meaning increased running costs.

Hybrid Home Heating Systems

Hybrid home heating systems are quickly becoming a popular option for homeowners looking to reap the benefits of both gas furnaces and electric heat pumps.

Hybrid home heating systems offer the best of both worlds for those seeking the efficiency and cost savings of a gas furnace bundled with the energy efficiency of a heat pump. Hybrid systems maintain a comfortable temperature by automatically utilizing whichever method is more appropriate at any given time, meaning you are sure to save energy in the long run while never having to sacrifice comfort.

Despite potentially higher up-front costs, these hybrid home heating systems offer great monetary savings in the long run by automatically adjusting temperatures based on your needs at any given moment.

If you’re considering a furnace for your home, there are many factors to keep in mind. But if you live in an area with particularly cold winters or want a more energy-efficient option, a heat pump might be the right choice for you.

Heat pumps are a great way to keep your home warm without having to use natural gas. They offer significant energy savings in the long run and can be used in combination with other heating systems for even greater efficiency.

While there may be some upfront costs associated with a new system, the cost savings over time make it an attractive option to many homeowners. If you’re looking for an energy-efficient and eco-friendly way to stay warm during the winter months, contact us to receive a quote for installing a heat pump in your home today. If you live in an area with generally mild winters, a heat pump should be your first choice for residential heating.

If you're looking for a reliable and long-lasting heat pump, contact HeatPumps.ca. Our track record of faithful operation and longevity is a testament to our commitment to quality. Additionally, be sure to check out our heat pump rebates and incentives to save even more money.

Toronto & Area:
Georgian Bay & Cottage Country Area:
1910A Kipling Ave
Etobicoke, ON M9W 4J1
Ontario Heat Pump Rebates

Discover how to significantly reduce your Heat Pump Installation costs. Secure up to 6.5K through Ontario's Heat Pump Rebate Program.

Connect with Us

  • qxio-social-facebook
  • qxio-social-google
  • qxio-star